Friday, July 15, 2016

Some Questions About Extreme Cases

From guest blogger, Rachel.

I think basic human nature/conscious is peace, and trying to help others; not violence. It is when resources are limited or a conundrum interferes that leads to a disruption in this thinking. For example, there are two people and you have to kill one, which one would you choose? Normally, I would want more information; what about you?. If one were a murderer and the other were a teacher, then to return to the human nature of peace, you would choose the murderer; if you wouldn’t, tell me why not. But what if the murderer killed someone who was a serial killer of children, and ended their reign? And the teacher taught racism and prejudice? Which would be better to kill?... it keeps getting more complicated. Or is it better to not kill either, because it’s not for us to decide?

Overall, I am looking forward to applying what we have learned this past week to the debates we are going to encounter in the future and use the logical tools and theories we have learned to communicate with other people who think differently from us.

Slavery and the Principle of Universalizability

From guest blogger,  Catherine.

In class we talked about many of the objections to Kant’s Principle of Universalizability, such as being able to get away with anything morally if you phrase your maxim in just the right way, or that it could condemn an action most would consider morally right as in the example of leaving a football game early to beat traffic is impossible to universalize because it’s self defeating but doesn’t seem inherently wrong.

However, by using the Principle of Universalizability, assuming you phrase your maxim in a coherent way, you should get the desired effect and be able to determine what most would agree upon as moral or immoral, but in some instances it seems to come to the conclusion with the wrong reasons. Take slavery for example, is slavery wrong just because everyone one isn’t able to do it or is it wrong because it is a violation of a person’s dignity? Sure the Principle of Humanity can be brought in to provide that reasoning but on it’s own this seems like a bit of a shortcoming for Universalizability.

Time-sensitivity and Consequentialism

From guest blogger, Aria.

From a utilitarian perspective, pleasure is the one and only intrinsic good. It states that the morally right action is the one that maximizes the pleasure to pain ratio. Thus, in order to make a decision about what we ought to do in a given situation, we need to calculate the total resultant pain and pleasure. The utilitarian believes that regardless of how difficult it is to predict the net amount of happiness/pleasure, we are morally required to do the best we can, give what we know to predict the consequences.

In my opinion, this view does not fully account for the complexity of time-sensitive dilemmas one could face, when one only has a few seconds to do the calculations and make a decision. To me, the limitation of time and the psychological pressure and strain it could result, greatly impairs the ability of the individual to do calculations and come up with a decision. How are we supposed to calculate the total amount of pain and pleasure and make a decision given the limited time and the complexity of the situation at hand? Consider the trolley problem when you have 3 seconds to decide whether you pull the lever to save the two individuals on the main track but kill the individual tied to the side track, or not pull the lever and let the two individuals tied to the main track die (there could also be a question about whether the utilitarian discriminates between killing vs. letting die). How are you supposed to have time to think about the issue at hand, make calculations, and decide what you ought to do to maximize the net pleasure or happiness in the 3 seconds you have? To me, the utilitarian’s claim that we ought to do the best we can, given what we know is not sufficient in such a complex situation. It seems to me that the utilitarian fails to consider the complexity and time sensitivity of real life dilemmas and does not provide appropriate guidance in such situations.

Furthermore, the utilitarian claims that the one and only intrinsic good is pleasure. But Why? She does not explain why pleasure is the only intrinsic good and why, for instance, knowledge/wisdom is not. I believe that the burden of proof is on the utilitarian to explain this.

Consider the trolley problem again but this time with only one individual tied to each track. Assume that you know that the two individuals are similar in every regard (e.g. they are clones of one another) and we have calculated the net amount of pleasure each of the individuals contributes to the world to be exactly the same. What are we supposed to do in this situation? Who are we supposed to save? Are you supposed to do nothing and let the person on the track die? Are you supposed to divert the track? The utilitarian seems to fail to give us an answer in this situation.

Now, consider a scenario when both of the people tied on the tracks (the main and side tracks) are similar in every regard, except that one individual is more attractive than the other. According to the principle of utility, you are supposed to save the more attractive individual since people get more pleasure just by looking at the person as they pass by her on the street. But is that the right thing to do? Aren’t looks the most superficial criteria to use to base our moral decisions on? To me, this does not seem like the moral thing to do. Thus, sometimes acts that seem immoral are morally required by the utilitarian principles.


What do you think the utilitarian’s response would be to these objections?

Deontology and Equal Treatment in Commerce

From guest blogger, Olivia.

Weddings in countries across the world are a time a great celebrations and confusing amongst families, but another layered was added for this Oregon family. The United States has always had a seeming complicated relationship with the LGBTQ community it comes to politics when the country rests on Christian values that they were allegedly founded on. The case in which the bakery located in Oregon denied service to a same sex couple that was looking to buy a wedding cake. The owners are Christian who firmly believe that marriage is between a man and a woman, and being involved in their wedding would contradict her beliefs. [She] is more than willing to bake cakes for gays, just not for weddings. Despite the legal ramifications of her decision, we can look at whether or not the decision she made was a moral one.

If viewing through the eyes of Kant, we can use is second gloss which states, “Always treat humanity, whether yourself or others as an end and not simply as a means.” If the couples that means to get married is assumed to be both autonomous and rational, then the store owner’s personal disposition has less value in whether or not a cake is sold. A business/client relationship should be treated with dignity and respect, and as a part of the relationship, a fair exchange without mentioning of personal beliefs would be the moral thing to do; therefore, the bakery owner acted immorally. Her actions inadvertently called the couple irrational, like a child or animal, because of their sexual orientation.

Moral Relativism vs. Moral Objectivism

From guest blogger, Alex.

In class we talked about the difference between moral relativism and moral objectivism. Moral relativism is the view that what is morally right or wrong depends on what someone thinks. We discussed two different types of moral relativism; simple subjectivism and cultural relativism. Simple subjectivism states that what is morally right or wrong for you depends on what you think is morally right or wrong, i.e., right or wrong is relative to the individual. Therefore 'moral facts' may alter from person to person. Cultural relativism states that what is morally right or wrong depends on what the society we are dealing with thinks, i.e., morality depends on the conventions of the society we are concerned with. Therefore 'moral facts' may alter from society to society. On the other hand moral objectivism  is the view that what is right or wrong doesn’t depend on what anyone thinks is right or wrong but instead states that the 'moral facts' are like 'physical' facts in that what the facts are does not depend on what anyone thinks they are. We talked about two kinds of moral objectivists in class; Deontologists and Consequentialists. Deontologists claim that what determines whether an act is morally right or wrong is the kind of act it is. Kant thought that all acts should be judged according to a rule he called the Categorical Imperative: "Act only according to that maxim [i.e., rule] whereby you can at the same time will that it become a universal law." That is, he thought the only kind of act one should ever commit is one that could be willed to be a universal law. Where Consequentialists claim that what determines whether an act is right or wrong are its consequences. Utilitarianism is the most common kind of Consequentialism. Utilitarianism tells us that, in any situation, the right thing to do is whatever is likely to produce the most happiness overall.

I was reading through some random scholarly journal I found through Google pertaining to the idea of moral relativism versus moral objectivism and it claimed that moral relativism has become an increasingly popular viewpoint in the latter part of the 20th century to the present day. I Thought “Why could this be?” I thought of and put together a couple possible reasons below. Feel free to comment on why you think this may be true, or why you think this statement is false. One reason could be the decline of religion. Religion seems to offer the possibility that morality was independent of us. With a turning away from religion there seems to have come a certain amount of doubt about the possibility of objective morality. But does it make sense to say that if there's no God, there's no such thing as morality? Another reason could come from observing cultural diversity. Most of us are aware that the world contains many different cultures and that some of those cultures engage in practices very different from our own. Maybe given all this diversity, we should conclude that there is no single objective morality and that morality varies with culture. Is this a fair conclusion and a good argument for moral relativism? Again, comments are welcome.

Impartiality and Consequentialism

From guest blogger, Alexander.

After learning about multiple theories to address and combat moral issues, I feel that consequentialism is not an accurate measurement of morality. On paper, the “maximization of total aggregate happiness” sounds great. However, it ends up screwing the non-happy portion. The first idea that I do not agree with is impartiality, that all beings are counted as equal. As great as this sounds, a lizard’s happiness is nowhere near equal to a human being’s. A consequentialist might say that happiness is a measure that should account for all beings on earth, but I don’t think that’s remotely true. For this theory, I believe human happiness should be above all else. Obviously, there would need to be exceptions to immoral cases like animal cruelty for this addition to benefit the theory. But, I think, with exceptions, human happiness is the most important. The second problem that I have with consequentialism is the inability to accurately assess immoral situations. The first example coming to mind is slavery. One largely populated group is happy, while a minority is very unhappy. In this case, it is morally acceptable. Slavery sets an example to several other immoral situations, like torture, kidnapping, or murder. If one party has more happiness than the unhappiness of the other, than it is moral. Which, obviously, is not the case. I believe the cause of pain or hurt should be counted in more than the “happiness” in the situation. In my opinion, pain is much more significant than happiness, and it takes a bigger toll on you. The goal should be to attempt to minimize or eliminate pain while still maintaining the highest possible amount of happiness. 

Consequentialism and Deontology and Long-term Results

From guest blogger, Hannah.

It is interesting to compare the consequentialist emphasis on long-term results and the deontologist’s emphasis on intention and motive. This contradiction is especially vital when trying to define someone’s moral character. Consequentialists believe that acts are moral because they are maximizing the goodness in the world by choosing the optimific action, one that results in the greatest balance of benefits over drawbacks. However, it is impossible to know the ultimate results an action will lead to years in the future and deontology views the intentions of the action the most important to define morality. For example, someone who is deciding whether or not to have an abortion can’t know if their child will find the cure for cancer or become the next world dictator, she only knows her current situation. For this reason, consequentialist decisions require a lot of speculation. In this example, if the woman didn’t have the abortion and her child found the cure for cancer, she would be told her decision was moral because it had a great benefit to society. However, if she didn’t have the abortion because she felt her current living situation would not be healthy to raise a child in, that would be moral according to deontology because she has the right intentions.

Another example that assumes less speculation is regarding drone strikes of terrorist bases. Many drone strikes have ended with innocent civilians being killed, leading drone strikes to be a controversial decision for a government to make. Consequentialists would take an interesting approach. They feel that although some innocent civilians are being killed, these strikes also kill terrorists who would have killed more people than those killed in the drone strike. These terrorists who died would have spread their mantras and encouraged other people to kill in the name of their organization. For this reason, the decision to have drone strikes would be the optimific one because the few deaths are not as bad as many. On the other hand, deontologist’s believe that the intentions are immoral because they are using the civilians as a mere means to kill terrorists, rather than treating them as an end and a part of humanity.


I personally believe that a person’s intentions should be the most important factor of their moral character. It does not make sense for someone with bad intentions to be considered moral because of “moral luck” or someone with good intentions to be considered immoral because of “moral bad luck”. What do you think? Do you have any other examples of times where it makes sense to look at intentions over future consequences or vice-versa? 

Are we capable of being moral if free will is just an illusion?

From guest blogger, Leona.

In Kant’s view of morality, there are two important conditions of humanity that came into play: autonomy and rationality. A way to attack this assumption mentioned by is The Argument against Autonomy that was included in Shafer-Landau’s book. Essentially, it aims to prove that our choices are out of our control. While the argument provide a philosophical prospective, psychologist are also looking into the matter of free will and decision making. There was a proposal made by Dan Wegner and Thalia Wheatley about two decades ago. If proved, it would render free will an illusion as well as the Kantian morality. The proposal suggested that our brain might justify our choices after it was made and gave us the illusion of intention. A paper came out early this year by Adam Bear and Paul Bloom from Yale might gave some solid evidence for this hypothesis. They conducted experiment showing 5 white circles on the screen and one of them will turn red in seconds. The subjects were instructed to guess one that would turn red. The final result showed that the chances the subjects chose the right circle was about 30%, which is much higher than the probability. It should be noted that this is a very simple decision making process and might not illustrate what happens in more complicated decision making. Moreover, even the 30% result is statistically significant, it also shows that choices could be illusions at times, but not always (in that case the subjects would “guess” the right circles all the time). Still, personally speaking, scientific discovery like this would make me leaning towards nihilism. 

Reference: Bear, A. (2016). What Neuroscience Says about Free Will. Scientific American Blog Network. Retrieved 15 July 2016, from http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/mind-guest-blog/what-neuroscience-says-about-free-will/

Virtue Ethics and Capital Punishment

From guest blogger, William.

How would a virtue ethicist approach capital punishment? It is a question that is more complicated than it seems. The two other philosophical views that were discussed in class hold clear views on capital punishment. Strict deontologists would support capital punishment. The readings for this class show this. Shafer-Landau spends a lot of time discussing how Kant determined how punishment should be morally speaking. Kant and other deontologists believe that criminals should be treated the same way they treated their victims. Capital punishment to them is morally okay. Consequentialism as well believes that capital punishment is morally okay. Consequentialists would mainly look at the positive consequences of capital punishment, such as criminal deterrence and prevention of further crimes committed by the criminal upon their release from prison. To a consequentialist the death of one person is fine, because it generates greater overall happiness in the community.

Thought experiments help show how much virtue ethics struggles with morality and capital punishment. A man on death row for murder. The man in question lived a virtuous life before committing his crime. Is he still a virtuous man even though he committed a heinous crime? Virtue ethics struggles to come to a concrete decision in this case. This is because virtue ethics does not look at just at a person’s action, but the person’s life as well. Taking the man’s life into consideration, a virtue ethicist must consider the death penalty as punishment for this man’s crime to be unjust and immoral. This example also shows another issue with virtue ethics. It does not explicitly state what makes a virtue a virtue. Is capital punishment in this case justice or revenge? Virtue ethics does not answer this question, because virtue ethics only states being morally right comes from being virtuous. It does not answer conflicts about what actions are virtuous.

There is a group of people that I have neglected in this post so far: the executioners. That is because virtue ethics does not cover the moral dilemma faced by executioners. If executioners killed those who were actively hurting innocent people, there would be no moral quandary. But, executioners kill powerless people. A prisoner on death row is completely helpless. This creates two questions. Are the actions of an executioner virtuous? Does executing prisoners make an executioner a virtuous person? To a virtue ethicist the answer to both of these questions is no. The job of an executioner is to murder a helpless individual. A virtuous person would not kill a handcuffed person, regardless of who they are. This allows us to answer the second question. The actions of an executioner cannot make the executioner a more virtuous person, because the actions undertaken by the executioner are not virtuous.

I personally believe that virtue ethics is quite weak when it comes to these situations. The criticisms of virtue ethics can be seen quite clearly when applying it to something like the death penalty and capital punishment. While consequentialism and deontology have quick answers to this moral question, virtue ethics flounders. This is because virtue ethics mainly describes and does not prescribe. In the end a proper virtue ethicist would be against capital punishment, but their argument would be quite weak.